Cuisine Guide

Top Rated — Best Italian in South London

Discover handpicked Italian restaurants in South London, with what to order first at each place.

Every place here is handpicked. Signal score shows how strong and consistent the review coverage is, not a star rating.

10 restaurants

1
Padella

Italian · £ · Southwark

93Signal

Start with

Pici Cacio e Pepe

Described as 'critically acclaimed' and 'so simple, so diet-destroying,' this signature dish is a benchmark for the restaurant's hand-rolled pasta.

Strong, consistent praise across multiple sources.

2
Baccalà

Italian Seafood · £££ · Bermondsey

91Signal

Start with

Roasted octopus with 'colonnata' lard

Described as a 'bonafide home run' by Square Mile, this starter featuring marinated bell peppers and olives is noted for leaving diners 'wanting more.'

Strong, consistent praise across multiple sources.

3
Artusi

Italian · £££ · Peckham

88Signal

Start with

Pappardelle with Lamb Shoulder Ragu

Jay Rayner calls these 'broad, silky ribbons' a 'standard bearer' for the restaurant, featuring meat cooked down until only the 'deep flavor' remains.

Strong, consistent praise across multiple sources.

4
Maremma

Tuscan Italian · ££ · Brixton

87Signal

Start with

Tortelli Maremmani

These cheese and ricotta stuffed dumplings are a visual highlight of the menu; critics who skip them report 'kicking themselves' when they see the dish served at other tables.

Strong, consistent praise across multiple sources.

5
Flour & Grape

Italian · ££ · Bermondsey

85Signal

Start with

Roasted Pork Shoulder Tortelloni

Described as a 'clear winner' that is 'stuffed to within an inch of its life' and served simply with sage butter.

Strong, consistent praise across multiple sources.

6
Legare

Italian · £££ · Southwark

85Signal

Start with

Pappardelle with Fennel Sausage Ragù and Cavolo Nero

Described as the 'main event,' these broad, al dente ribbons are wrapped in a rich ragù that critics call 'meaty, carb-laden goodness.'

Strong, consistent praise across multiple sources.

7
Sorella

Italian · £££ · Clapham

82Signal

Start with

Truffle Arancini

Described as 'small, feisty truffle arancini,' these are a staple starter at this neighborhood joint that are consistently praised for their flavor.

Strong, consistent praise across multiple sources.

8
Marcella

Italian · ££ · Deptford

82Signal

Start with

Seasonal Ragu Pasta

Whether it's ox cheek, beef shin, or venison, the slow-cooked meat ragu pastas (often pappardelle) are consistently rated as rich, comforting, and technically perfect.

Strong, consistent praise across multiple sources.

9
Italo

Italian Cafe & Deli · ££ · Vauxhall

82Signal

Start with

Italian-style Sandwiches

Generously filled with seasonal ingredients like mortadella and sweet peppers.

Strong, consistent praise across multiple sources.

10
Guido’s

Italian · ££ · Dulwich

82Signal

Start with

Cacio e pepe pasta

The quintessential must-order dish supplied by the editor.

Strong, consistent praise across multiple sources.

Explore more collections