Curated Collection

Top Rated in Mayfair

Discover handpicked top rated in Mayfair, London, with what to order first at each place.

Every place here is handpicked. Signal score shows how strong and consistent the review coverage is, not a star rating.

15 restaurants

1
The Cocochine

Modern French / Sri Lankan · ££££ · Mayfair

95Signal

Start with

Tanera Island Native Lobster in Banana Leaf

Sourced from private Scottish waters and barbecued in banana leaves with wild cardamon and red wine jus, this dish is consistently cited by critics as the kitchen's standout showcase of high-end produce.

Strong, consistent praise across multiple sources.

2
Noble Rot Mayfair

Modern European · ££££ · Mayfair

95Signal

Start with

Duck Egg Custard Tart

Regarded as a signature dessert, critics describe it as 'quite wonderful' and 'SO GOOD.' Its pedigree stems from the head chef's training with Marcus Wareing, who famously served a version to the Queen.

Strong, consistent praise across multiple sources.

3
The Ritz Restaurant

French / British · ££££ · Mayfair

91Signal

Start with

Langoustine À La Nage

Universally cited as a masterpiece; huge, sweet crustaceans served in a rich, buttery sauce with bronze fennel.

Strong, consistent praise across multiple sources.

4
Claridge's Restaurant

British · ££££ · Mayfair

90Signal

Start with

Black Truffle Buckwheat Crumpets

Described as 'unusual and lovely,' these starters are topped with 'curly slivers of truffle' and represent a defining signature of the restaurant's new identity.

Strong, consistent praise across multiple sources.

5
El Asador At Sabor

Spanish · £££ · Mayfair

90Signal

Start with

Galician Tortilla

This Basque-style omelette is synonymous with Chef Barragán; it is famously runny inside with lots of soft sliced potato and is considered some of the best Spanish food in London.

Strong, consistent praise across multiple sources.

6
The Grill at The Dorchester

Modern British Grill · ££££ · Mayfair

88Signal

Start with

Welsh Rarebit Crumpet

Described as 'heavenly,' 'light, fluffy and zingy' with the tang of good cheese and plenty of Worcestershire sauce.

Strong, consistent praise across multiple sources.

7
Corrigan's Mayfair

British / Irish / Game · ££££ · Mayfair

88Signal

Start with

Roe Venison en Croute

Acclaimed as "simply the best venison dish" a critic has ever had, it features "huge chunks of stunningly good, ruby-red roe" paired with pickled red cabbage and a "wonderful" cep sauce.

Strong, consistent praise across multiple sources.

8
Bentley's Oyster Bar & Grill

Seafood · ££££ · Mayfair

86Signal

Start with

Bentley’s Fish Pie

Described as the 'essence of a PG Wodehouse novel' and made by someone who 'understands the engineering of the dish,' it features a piped golden mash over smoked haddock, salmon, and prawns.

Strong, consistent praise across multiple sources.

9
Manthan

Modern Indian · £££ · Mayfair

85Signal

Start with

Ghati Masala Prawns

Regarded as a highlight of the menu, these prawns are described as 'delicate but fiercely flavoured' and are a go-to recommendation for those new to Rohit Ghai's cooking.

Strong, consistent praise across multiple sources.

10
Murano

Modern Italian · ££££ · Mayfair

84Signal

Start with

Tagliatelle with roast ceps/porcini and 24-month aged Parmesan Reggiano

Reviewers highlight the 'excellent texture' of the hand-made pasta combined with the 'earthy mushroom flavour' and the 'richness of the cheese.'

Strong, consistent praise across multiple sources.

11
Bibi

Modern Indian · ££££ · Mayfair

84Signal

Start with

Sharmaji’s Lahori Chicken

Critics describe this succulent dish as 'tender grilled' chicken served in a 'rich cashew and yoghurt whey sauce' that diners 'rave about for days.'

Strong, consistent praise across multiple sources.

12
Crisp

Pizza · ££ · Mayfair

84Signal

Start with

Vecna Pie

The fan favourite from the original Hammersmith location is loaded with pepperoni, burrata, and hot honey on a perfectly charred crust. It is a social media sensation that manages to live up to the expectations.

Strong, consistent praise across multiple sources.

13
Hélène Darroze at The Connaught

French Fine Dining · ££££ · Mayfair

82Signal

Start with

Lobster with Tandoori Spices

Cited by critics as the unwavering signature dish; it is the one menu item that never changes and is seen as justifying the restaurant's Michelin stars.

Strong, consistent praise across multiple sources.

14
The Connaught Bar

Cocktails · ££££ · Mayfair

82Signal

Start with

Connaught Martini

The bar's signature bespoke Dry Martini is a 'headline act' where the serve becomes a performance, arriving by trolley and poured into a bitters-adorned glass from overhead.

Strong, consistent praise across multiple sources.

15
HIDE

Modern European · ££££ · Mayfair

80Signal

Start with

White Asparagus in Salty Hazelnut Praline

Described by The Guardian as 'filthily good' and leaving the critic 'hair-tossingly ecstatic,' it is a standout example of the restaurant's vegetable-forward refinement.

Strong, consistent praise across multiple sources.

Explore more collections